The oldest surviving lighthouse on the Great Lakes, with a ghost story attached
Gibraltar Point Lighthouse
Built in 1808, the Gibraltar Point Lighthouse on the Toronto Islands is the oldest surviving lighthouse on the Great Lakes, and local legend holds that its first keeper was murdered and never found.
.jpg)
Advertisement
The Gibraltar Point Lighthouse was built in 1808 on the Toronto Islands, making it the oldest surviving lighthouse on any of the Great Lakes, constructed to help guide ships into Toronto's harbour at a time when the town of York was still a young settlement. The stone tower has stood for over two centuries, though it stopped functioning as an active navigational aid decades ago as the surrounding shoreline shifted and newer lights took over the job.
A murder that was never solved
Local legend holds that the lighthouse's first keeper, John Paul Radelmüller, was murdered on the site in 1815, allegedly by soldiers he had refused to sell liquor to, with his body reportedly never found despite years of searching — a story that has made the lighthouse one of Toronto's most persistently repeated ghost stories. Whatever the truth of the legend, the lighthouse remains a protected heritage structure and one of the oldest standing buildings in Toronto, a physical link to the city's earliest maritime history.
Advertisement
Sources
Continue reading
The Toronto Island Ferries
Getting to the Toronto Islands has meant a ferry since the 19th century — the only way to reach North…
The Distillery District
Once the Gooderham and Worts distillery, at one point the largest in the British Empire, the Distillery…
The Ward
For nearly a century, the crowded downtown district known as the Ward served as Toronto's first stop for…
.jpg)
Ontario Place
A Modernist waterfront park that drew millions of visitors a year in the 1970s, closed its main attractions…